top of page

On the Proper Orthodox Stance Toward Heresy

A friend wrote the following (to which I respond further down):

"To give away a holy site does not seem right. But a compromise might be to let Roman Catholics uild their own modest chapel on the isle. In many places Orthodox and Catholics must share and ooperate in the Holy Land, especially. At the top of Mt Tabor, for example, is an older Catholic hurch and a newer Orthodox church (and monastery, I believe). Where it is possible, we should be haritable, but not foolishly give away our oil before the Groom comes."

~ It seems to me that your response is very reasonable and quite human and logical. However, it may also be lacking in a true and proper understanding of the catastrophic implications of heresy for the salvation of man and the unity of the Church.

Heresy is so hated by the holy fathers and the Church precisely because it deprives men of the grace of God, that is, of communion with the person of Christ, Who is our salvation. This is so because the grace of God is the spirit of Truth and there is no untruth in Him.

The line that which separates Orthodoxy from heresy is not a line simply between "enlightened" theology and a confused theology, but precisely between Theanthropic existence and merely human existence, between revelation and religion.

If, then, the Papal religious system is indeed heresy, as Saint Mark of Ephesus and all subsequent holy fathers maintained, is it possible for the Orthodox Shepherd to cooperate in the establishment of a heretical parasynagogue in the midst of the faithful and in such a holy place? Would this be spiritually responsible? Is that what the holy fathers have taught us?

It is quite apparent that the Patriarch/ate does not believe the papal religious system represents heresy but rather The Church itself (a belief which expresses the heresy of ecumenism) and therefore has no qualms giving the holy "dogs" (=spiritually speaking, always)! And if one gives holy things to those who cannot and do not fulfill the presuppositions to commune of them, it may mean that he himself does not fulfill those presuppositions, but has fallen away from the all-discerning Spirit.~…/05/blog-post_22.h…

Comment Share Share Tweet Email

10 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page